3.5/5 stars
Gallery Books, 2013
292 pages
Adult Historical Fiction
Scheduled for release January 15
Source: Received an e-ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Although technically an adult book, I think YA bloggers may be interested in it, appreciating that it is a clean read. That plus the fact that I'm a sucker for historical fiction, especially those whose summary hints at parallels to "Downton Abbey," which I felt this book's did, were the main reasons I wanted to read this. I also love the presence of a sisters relationship, a theme for which I have a soft spot. Additionally I loved the cover with its pretty dress. So I entered this book with high expectations. But being kind of a weirdo, I had a mixed experience.
There are three main characters: Rowena, Victoria, and Prudence. Although Prudence is the daughter of the first two girls' governess, she has been included as part of the family by the father. After his untimely death though, the two daughters are warmly welcomed into their ancestral home at Summerset Abbey while Prudence is relegated to the role of lady's maid. Both of the daughters are upset that Prudence is being separated but Rowena mostly passively accepts the distinction while the delicate Victoria rages against the slight. Thereby Victoria and Prudence are established as the more sympathetic characters with Rowena frequently shown as incapable and mostly unwilling of doing anything to change their circumstances.
As the establishing book in the series, I felt like a lot of plot threads were introduced but none were really dealt with. Rowena develops an interest in flight as well as in a neighbor boy while Victoria toils to learn typing in addition to juggling her own flirtation. Prudence's story moves the most as she learns a shocking family secret and entertains two gentlemen friends (okay, it doesn't go that far but she has two men express interest in her). There are also cousins of similar age who are bristling against the constraints of Edwardian tradition (just wait for the Great War boys!) But I found them all so boring.
Honestly my favorite character was Lady Summerset (aunt to Rowena and Victoria) with her iron will. However I don't think you were supposed to like her as she schemes against Prudence, planning to put her in her place. Since I didn't care for Prudence but I like strong characters, Lady Summerset was awesome. The three main characters suffer as women in a man's world but Lady Summerset suffered in her own way. She carefully manages her household and would certainly be a force to be reckoned with if she was allowed into politics or business; instead she observes and she arranges through her husband as best she can. I wanted more of her (I guess she kind of reminded me of Lady Violet in Downton Abbey :)
Because I found the three leads so dull, I struggled with this book. Still if reviews suggest that the second book picks up steam (perhaps the urgency of war will illuminate it? Not sure if we'll be at the brink of war yet), I would be interested in continuing.
Other Opinions:
Confessions of an Opinionated Book Geek: 3.5/5 stars
Katie's Book Blog: 4/5 stars
One Page at a Time: 4/5 stars
Sweet Tidbits: 2.5/5 stars
It's a shame the leads are dull. This sounds like it's cashing in on Downton Abbey's success.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds interesting...
ReplyDeletei don't do much HF so I will probably pass, but it seems like it is setting up a lot for the next book.
ReplyDeleteHappy reading,
Brandi from Blkosiner’s Book Blog
All the Downton Abbey-inspired books I have read have had a lot of intersecting plot threads but lackluster characters.
ReplyDeleteThe cover really is lovely. I'm not a big fan of "establishing" books. I think the first book should still be able to stand on its own.
ReplyDeleteI love the sounds of this. Too bad some of the characters were dull, but the rest of the book sounds great! Awesome review :)
ReplyDelete"Meh" heroines make it hard to get invested in a book. I was intrigued by this because of the Downton ABeey reference (and for some reason I didn't realize it was an adult title!) so I appreciate the honest review.
ReplyDeleteWendy @ The Midnight Garden
I've never seen Downton Abbey but the title of this immediately made me think of it! haha Bummer you didn't find it nearly as compelling as you thought you some.
ReplyDeleteAnd sometimes the "bad" characters really are the best, simply because they are so interesting! Sorry nobody else really stuck out. i do like some good characters in my fiction. :)
Historical fiction normally isn't something I read a lot of, but I really like the sounds of this one though. Family drama... Great review. :)
ReplyDeleteJenea @ Books Live Forever
I like this book so far though Rowena and Victoria can be annoying. I like Prudence anyway. I haven't read very much of it yet so we shall see...
ReplyDeleteSometimes mean characters can be fun. That is why Thomas and O'Brian are so interesting on Downton Abbey :)
All three girls from Summerset Abbey disappointed me in the end, but Prudence most of all. Rowena I gave up on first, then Victoria and, finally Prudence. Especially at the end. But then, I hate it when MCs do what Prudence did thinking it will actually be some kind of solution to her problem(s).
ReplyDelete