The Tutor's Daughter

The Tutor's Daughter by Julie Klassen
4/5 stars
Bethany House, 2013
409 pages
Adult Historical Christian Romance

Source: Received an e-ARC via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

I had read an earlier title by Klassen (The Girl in the Gatehouse) and was primed to enjoy another title from her, having liked her homages to Jane Austen. As an Austenite, I am always happy to read other books with references to the time and even events of Austen's plots. Additionally I liked the title's hint at something involving education while also including romance obviously.

Let's start with a wide view of this book. Emma, the titular tutor's daughter, wishes to help her widowed father regain a connection to the outside world. Thus she writes to the father of former pupils and he is contracted as a private tutor for his two youngest sons, bringing Emma along as an assistant. Before too long, all the sons of the family are at the manor in addition to the lord, lady, lady's ward, and servants. But there are many mysteries within this house...can Emma unravel them all, including which of the charming brothers is worth her heart?

Readers of the book will notice distinct plot plots akin to those of beloved novels Sense and Sensibility as well as Jane Eyre. Sure enough, Klassen references her love in the author's note at the end. Fear not-though on the surface, there are similarities but they play out vastly differently. I especially liked the plot that reminded me of Jane Eyre specifically because of the differences that helped to shake up this otherwise pretty predictable story. Sorry for not being more specific but I'm trying to avoid spoilers.

I guess there's also a bit of Pride and Prejudice as the tutor's daughter Emma had a very negative first impression of Henry that caused her to hold a grudge but this reunion allows him the opportunity to demonstrate maturity. I found Emma a little bit too perfect, lacking the rough edges that allow you to feel like you could be the character or like you know someone like her. I guess maybe she's a little rigid in her opinions but she doesn't have that indefinable spark for me.

One last element to mention is the Christian elements. I personally didn't find them to be very present at all but that is how it is classified and someone who is not Christian may find it to be too much. Emma does not have much faith but through some circumstances in the book, as well as her love interest, she does develop more faith.

Overall: Leisurely paced historical chaste-romance novel-definitely great for fans of Klassen's other work!

The Girl in the Gatehouse

The Girl in the Gatehouse by Julie Klassen

Bethany House, 2010

391 pages

Historical Christian Romance

4/5 stars

Source: Library

I tried to read The Apothecary's Daughter last year and was disappointed, leading me to label it a DNF.  But I thought this would be different when I opened the book to a quote from Mansfield Park and saw character names bringing to mind that book.  Anything that closely influenced by Austen will probably please me and this mostly did so.

Mariah has been kicked out by her father for her indiscretion and she goes to live in the gatehouse of her aunt's estate, contenting herself with novel writing and spinsterhood.  After her aunt's death, young Captain Bryant lets the house.  He is set on marrying a girl who previously spurned him as beneath her but also develops a friendship with Mariah.  Obviously a romance blossoms but I felt that their story was the weakest overall.  Mariah's feelings over her disgrace, despite being historically accurate, grated on me.  And Bryant acted like a jerk to her; luckily he has a friend who tells him so.

Besides the main romance, there were many subplots-too many in my opinion.  Mariah's former governess and now companion, Dixon, ends up in a love triangle.  Mariah's aunt's stepson intrigues in multiple ways.  A mysterious man lives in the poorhouse across the way; his past is deeply tied to the estate and the sea.  And then there are several little stories in the poorhouse itself.  I enjoyed these subplots and I was able to keep them straight in my mind but I just felt that there were too many.

The writing is fine, without the sharp edge of Austen, but still good.  Historical details were sprinkled in especially about the writing process and how Mariah had to keep it secret because novel writing was scandalous.  The bit that jarred was when the rake who ruined Mariah confessed to such and talked about the double standard.  Would that have really happened? I think not.

The religious aspect was pretty low-key but basically revolves around Mariah needing to forgive herself and Bryant needing to stop striving for his father's good opinion and finding contentment in his Father's grace.  There weren't many Scripture references but there were more than a few discussions about forgiveness and the afterlife.

Overall: A story that owes a great debt to Austen and is a fast, enjoyable read.

Cover: I love the gatehouse, the actual gatehouse that inspired Klassen she shares, and the green and purple.

Read for Christian Fiction Book Club. Hosted by Joy at Edgy Inspirational Romance.

2.  Mariah's situation (sent away after an indiscretion to live in relative isolation) was loosely based on the fate of one of Jane Austen's characters in Mansfield Park (although Maria Bertram was a married woman who had an affair). Did you think Mariah Aubrey's father treated her unfairly? How have attitudes toward "virtue and vice" changed since the early 1800s?

I think her father was a bit unfair.  I understand his decision to send away his daughter because she had disgraced the family but I think her siblings could still have been allowed to interact with Mariah, especially Henry who as a male was held to different standards.  He also could have given her sufficient money by allowing her mother to designate an allowance.  In general attitudes are more permissive (at least in America, a non-virgin woman can still marry anyone) but the double standard persists: women are more likely to be labeled sluts while guys are cheered.  There does seem to be some lessening of that but not enough in my opinion.

6. Did you find yourself growing fond of any character that you did not care for at the outset? Which character was your favorite? Why?

At first I didn't like Dixon because she made me think of the character in North and South, who I don't like.  But this Dixon is quite different and her romance ended up being one of my favorite aspects.  As to a favorite character, I guess I liked Martin the most.  I wanted to like Mariah and Matthew but they had a couple of really annoying aspects to their story so Martin's general goodness shined through the best for me.