by Sara Zarr and Tara Altebrando
4/5 stars
Little, Brown and Company, 2013
279 pages
YA Contemporary
Source: Received an ARC through Amazon Vine in exchange for an honest review.
When I saw that this book was told in alternating perspectives and incorporating the use of emails, I was immediately sold. That put me in mind of beloved childhood read PS Longer Letter Later by Ann M. Martin and Paula Danziger. Though I was disappointed to discover it wasn't told exclusively through emails, I still loved the idea of future college roommates connecting the summer before freshman year and being impacted by that relationship. I did have a roommate my first year in college and we roomed again sophomore year but we were never that close. Our interests sharply diverged and we tended to be more ships passing in the night instead of close friends, which is fine. She maintained a standard of cleanliness I could live up to and she didn't bring weird people back to our room. Sometimes I wish we could have been best friends but it is what it is.
Which rambling brings me to the girls in our story, who seem wildly different at first but who learn important lessons about relationships through their email correspondence in the waning hours of their pre-college life. In New Jersey, we have Elizabeth who is bubbly and looking forward to big changes in Berkeley. Her roommate to be is Lauren, the eldest of six children in San Francisco seeking peace and quiet. Both experience ups and downs with boys, friends, and family over this crazy summer.
As I've shared before in my reviews, I'm a reader who loves epistolary novels so that was a huge draw for me. I got excited every time one popped up and felt they were used pretty well. They didn't overwhelm the reader but they effectively moved the plot along and reflected each girl's personality. I am guessing each author wrote exclusively for one character and felt that this contributed to keeping them distinct. A complaint I've seen of some dual narrators written by one author is that they feel too much the same and that is definitely not the case here.
I think I did end up preferring Lauren with her seriousness and commitment of family but Elizabeth was also a good character to read about. I know I sometimes will vastly prefer one narrator to the other but it was almost equally balanced here. There are also some great secondary characters; for me, that would mostly be the love interests but Lauren's parents have some touching moments too.
Overall: A funny sweet story that touches on something I haven't read much of before (college roommates to be, who knew?) while also touching on universal relatable themes in an extremely readable writing style.
We have yet to find a "duet" novel (written by two people) that we really love, but we adore Sara Zarr, and the premise of this sounds great, so we're feeling pretty optimistic about ROOMIES. Your review helps too. ;) Glad you enjoyed it!
ReplyDeleteI hope you like this one too-I tend to like the concept a lot and seek them out so I'll see if I can think of any other recs for you.
DeleteRoommates that don't bring weird people to the room are the best.
ReplyDeleteIn hindsight, that feels like an odd point to mention but thinking of stories I've heard from other people, it's actually something I really appreciate.
DeleteI kept going back and forth about which character I liked best, so I think I'm like you and I liked them equally. I'm glad you enjoyed this one as well!
ReplyDeleteIt was a tough decision-both won me over with sympathetic moments.
DeleteI would really like to get a copy of this, all the reviews make it sounds so good. :)
ReplyDeleteMaybe your library will get it? It's worth a read for lovers of contemporary.
DeleteI enjoyed this one too. I thought it was well done and sympathetic to both characters. I felt Elizabeth had the worse problems to overcome, but I liked Lauren's sense of balance and way of dealing with things better. At any rate, I wanted to read about this transition period and I thought the authors did a good job portraying it.
ReplyDeleteElizabeth had so much crappy stuff but I identified more with Lauren, personality-wise.
DeleteI can't wait to read this one. I'm glad to hear people are liking it.
ReplyDeleteI saw a lot of positive reviews beforehand so I was pretty optimistic going in and I'm glad that paid off.
DeleteI think that I would like Lauren being serious and her commitment to family that is something I love to read about
ReplyDeleteThat's what I liked about Lauren!
DeleteGlad you liked this one -- I really enjoyed it!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for stopping by! Jen @ YA Romantics
Your review was one of the reasons I wanted to read this :)
DeleteSo glad this one was a hit for you. I was just talking about Ann Martin last week & I added that book to my TBR list. It sounds great. I just loved Roomies so much. It came right when I needed to be hooked into a book and I truly related to what both girls were feeling. It's so interesting & also great commentary on the "internet" age.
ReplyDelete