Death by Petticoat by Mary Miley Theobald
3/5 stars
Andrew McMeel Publishing, LLC, 2012
126 pages
Non-fiction; American History
Source: Received an e-ARC via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
I love the idea for this book-it is right up my alley as a history major who specialized in US history. I love collections of truths and myths that break them down in easy-to-read ways and this looked like the perfect quick read for me.
And it was a quick read. Each entry is only about one page and includes a picture to further illustrate the point. The writing was easy to read and due to the shortness, you can very quickly read this book. I think it would be fun to pick it up and read an entry or two at a time. It looks like a nice book to support The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation and its missions of preservation and education.
However I ended up being disappointed on a few counts. First the focus is mostly on colonial times (which is forecast by the collaboration with The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation but which I didn't notice). I thought it would cover a longer period of time and be more mixed. But most of the myths come from colonial times with just a few from later days. Second was the myths themselves, most of which I had never even heard of-two separate mentions of room taxes as a for example. I guess these are questions that tourists ask when visiting Colonial Williamsburg, which makes me very worried for our school system if in fact American-educated people are thinking these things are true. My expectations were that I would have at least heard of the myths even if I knew they were false from my more specialized studying.
Overall: Good for some light reading but not recommended for history scholars.
Hehe. The title is so cute and awesome!! And the book seems great too!! I think I'll give this a go... I'm not anywhere near being a History scholar. :P Great review!! <3
ReplyDeletexx
Riya (The Teen Book Guru)
Although sometimes if something strikes a person's fancy, they might actually look it up... so it may not be a bad thing. However, I do get what you mean. If it is set in a specific time, the author should make it as authentic as possible. Great review!
ReplyDeleteWith you being a history major and all, that's why I always trust your historical recommendations! :) It's too bad that it let you down with the historical aspects, especially since it has such a fun title. But I don't know anything about The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, so I guess that it could throw anything at me and I wouldn't know the difference haha :')
ReplyDeleteAmazing honest review as always, B! Hopefully the next historical book blows you away even more! :) <3